CB Stuffer Peanut Butter Cups

(15 customer reviews)


CB Stuffer Gourmet Giant Peanut Butter Cups are the biggest and best available. These 5.5 oz peanut butter cups start with the best peanut butter and then expand flavors such as S’mores: graham crackers blended with peanut butter then topped with Fluff, Maple Walnut, Cookie Monstah and our newest Salted Pretzel which is peanut butter blended with pretzels and then topped with sea salt! For the New England lovers our Boston or our lobster is a traditional peanut butter cup topped with a solid decorative chocolate.


CB Stuffer Peanut Butter Cups

Our CB Stuffer Peanut Butter Cup is the largest on the market weighing in at 5.5 oz, these CB Stuffer Peanut Butter cups are available in an expanded flavor profile. These are grown up and stuffed! Enjoy the flavors of fall with our Maple Walnut Peanut Butter Cup. It’s made with real New England maple syrup.

Additional information

Weight N/A

Bacon Peanut Butter Cup, Dark Reading Rocket, Football adorned traditional peanut butter cup, Maple Walnut, Milk Reading Rocket, Milk Traditional, peamut butter & jelly, peanut butter & jelly, Toasted Coconut, Traditional Holiday, All Natural Dark Chocolate, All Natural Milk Chocolate, Boston, Bruins Style Boston, Caramel, Crispy Milk Chocolate Peanut Butter Cup, dark chocolate, Dark Chocolate Caramel & Sea Salt, Dark m&m Pretzel, Espresso, Fluffanutter, m&m, Milk m&m pretzel, Milk Salted Pretzel, New! Cookie Monstah, s'mores, Traditional Bacon, Traditional Dark, Traditional Milk "Lobstah", Traditional Valentine

15 reviews for CB Stuffer Peanut Butter Cups

  1. Kathii Lee Dwyer

    I must order a lifetime supply of dark chocolate peanut butter cups. I may loose my mind if I run out. I can’t afford to buy always so I’m thinking of selling some of my toys for more stuffers…;-)

    • Erin

      Kathii, thank you for continuing to love our products, especially of Facebook 🙂

  2. Mary Ellen Dawson

    Amazing! I buy these at a local farm where they have a small market. I skip all of the fruits and vegetables and head directly to the CB Stuffer peanut butter cups. Love these dark chocolate treats.

    • Erin

      Thank you so much for your post, which peanut butter cup is your favorite?

  3. Amanda Logee

    I really love the PB & J Cup. It’s so yummy! I’m glad I picked one up when I went to the local apple orchard, they are now my favorite. I have to take my time eating it because of its size.

    • Erin

      The PB&J is one of our favorites too!

  4. Peggy Panetti

    I never ate a piece of candy as good as your Dark Peanut Butter Cup…I have one bite left!!! My granddaughter bought one at Marshall’s because I am gluten intolerant and have to be sooooooo careful!!! Thank you for this wonderful treat!!!

    • Erin

      thank you Peggy, did you let the last bite last?

  5. Ana

    I’m so high on chocolate right now and I swear this is the best stuff I’ve ever had in my entire life

  6. Lisa Little

    There are many food items I love. High among them ranks chocolate, peanut butter and caramel. My husband bought me your CB Caramel Peanut Butter Cup at Marshalls for Christmas. I made the mistake of throwing the wrapper away as I placed the beautiful cup in a Tupperware shortly after Xmas to consume and store as I would a small pie. My intent was to cut a small piece off the cup each night which I did (though I did think A LOT about the cup between portions). With each taste I grew more addicted. I have had A LOT of peanut butter cups, but none tops this one. I was so sad to see the last piece go-especially not knowing where would I get another. Fortunately, I had returns to do at a Home Goods/ Marshalls. I purposefully drove cross town to a store I don’t normally go to, but where I knew my husband had purchased the cup. After visiting active wear (where I run off my dessert addictions) I headed straight for Specialty Foods. Hunting, like only a good Marshalls customer can, I looked high and low in the chocolate area to no avail. A worker was stocking in the aisle so I went to her describing the size and unbelievable taste of this product. I think if she hadn’t seen how serious I was about my inquiry she might have thought I was nuts. To my disappointment she could not help me. Well as any faithful Marshall shopper does, we do not give up. I headed to the back where all the Christmas Clearance items were, much of which were various chocolate and candy items. I dug through every shelf for 3 aisles. Then low and behold hidden among other items way in the back of a bottom shelf, there it was. I was ecstatic. I now had the name. Most importantly I now had another cup. These are awesome. Thank you for making such a perfect tasting product. I read your history and I love pizza, too. I grew up in Brooklyn, NY on some of the best pizza in the United States. I am as particular about my pizza as I am about my chocolate products. Your product is AWESOME.

    • Erin

      Thank you so much and I LOVE your detailed review 🙂 You can also do a search for other specialty stores near you which carry our products and you can always order online at cbstuffer.com 🙂

  7. Alex Scaglioni

    One of the best things I have ever purchased! The ones that I’ve had so far are to die for. I’m certain the rest are too.

  8. Melissa Burke

    The most AMAZING chocolate PB cup I’ve ever had!! My husband and I got the S’mores cup at the World of Wheels last weekend. We decided to enjoy it tonight. It was so DELICIOUS! I’m already craving another one!

    • Erin

      Thank you Melissa! Don’t forget you can order online and enter #getstuffed for 20% off your order.

  9. Marisa

    Omg! I cannot say more about this chocolate caramel peanut butter cup. Yes I can; it’s better than any chocolate I’ve tasted & I’m a recovering chocolate/addict. So I’ve tried lots of chocolate over my lifetime! Sooooo buttery! I found mine at Marshall’s. Wish I could find more. Loved It! Sorry Godiva!

    • Erin

      Thank you Marisa! You can find more through our online store and enter #getstuffed at checkout for a discount.

  10. Risbel

    I bought one to save for the weekend…but it didn’t even survive the next 24 hours after I purchased it. I must buy more!!!!

    • Erin

      Thanks for the share where did you purchase the cup?

    • Erin

      Yes, they are addictive! We’re running a promotion for Earth Day, when you enter #GOGREEN at checkout you’ll receive 25% off your order!

  11. Kyle Mullen

    Totally blown away!!!!! The s’mores is incredible! Definitely getting more!!!

    • Erin

      Thank you Kyle, we’re glad you enjoyed the s’mores!

  12. Jen Munro (verified owner)

    I ordered some variety pieces, very pleased with the salted pretzel peanut butter cups, gave half away to my good friends as little quarantine gifts, they told me they were very good as well I do wish there was more caramel in the caramel one but I could still taste it and it was sufficient. , Ordered it and once they put the order through it was delivered within 24 hours, I am only a state away but I was impressed by that. One of them was Reese‘s peanut butter cups and I don’t know what that one is called on the list or I would have ordered it again it was delicious! I just put through my second order. I was referred by a friend who raves about these chocolates.

    • Erin

      Thank you Jen, we’re proud of our CB Stuffer brand of products and are happy you enjoyed them. You mentioned a national brand, we don’t make that one and hopefully in the future when you think peanut butter cups you think CB Stuffer and not that other name 🙂

  13. tasty (verified owner)

    I shop on qvc.com, where they had a small business spotlight, for CB Stuffer, so HAPPY I found this small family run business, because I am a chocoholic, for sure!! I purchased the original milk chocolate, peanut butter cup, & the dark chocolate caramel sea salt, peanut butter cup! The packaging was AWESOME, pure luxury and high quality looking, so would make a GREAT GIFT! Next was the huge peanut butter cups, bigger is ALWAYS better, IMHO, the chocolate cup was very thick, had to use a strong knife, to cut into it, but found the peanut butter inside, was very smooth and creamy, but felt the peanut butter flavor, could be stronger, and more of it, for me personally, but it was still very good! Since the shell is so thick, with solid chocolate, is my reason for needing more peanut butter, filling. The dark chocolate caramel, was very decadent and rich, high quality for sure, so smooth, it just melts in your mouth, best dark chocolate I’ve ever tasted! I also purchased the dark chocolate, cranberry infused, artisan bar, this dark chocolate is so YUMMY and rich, with large cranberries! I break off a square, and shave it over my home made vanilla, ice cream…OMG this is pure heaven, so SCRUMPTIOUS!! You all ROCK, thanks so much for making such high quality, chocolates, so HAPPY I found YOU :-)!!!

    • Erin

      Thank you so much and make sure to use #getstuffed on social media and also use #getstuffed when shopping again for 20% off your online order. When you sign up to receive our emails you’ll also receive discounts and special offerings.

  14. Bucky

    Knock my socks off delicious! At Marshalls with my teen daughter, she spotted a PB cup and said she was going to buy it for herself if I wouldn’t buy it for her. Believe me when I say we have more than enough dessert in our house, so I told her she could pay for it herself (it’s not about the cost; it’s the principle. Did she want it badly enough to pay for it with her own money?), which she did. Then, I made her give me a bite! Oh, wow! The ratio of chocolate to PB is just right, given how huge the cup is. The thickness of the chocolate makes for a satisfying combination of flavor on the palate. The quality of the chocolate is so so much better than what I buy in the grocery store. Fast forward a month or so to two weeks ago when I was shopping in TJ Maxx. I discovered about 10 cups in their food section and recognized them instantly as the amazing PB cup from before. Despite my vowing not to bring home any more dessert or candy, I could not let this golden opportunity slip by. I bought five. Had to leave some for the other customers, right? I will now be on the lookout for other CB Stuffer products and will not hesitate to buy when I spot them. Resisting the online buying option is how I have chosen to show restraint. Let’s see how long that lasts.

    • Erin

      Thank you so much for your positive review! Whenever you want to shop online be sure to use the code #getstuffed for 20% off your order!

  15. Kimmi

    I cannot get enough of these PB Cups!!! They are DELICIOUS! I originally bought as stocking stuffers for Christmas; now I buy just to have in the house and as gifts for no reason at all! I cannot get enough of them; I especially love to pair them with raspberry lemonade. Although I love the minis, I love the giant size more because the amount of peanut butter is magic in my mouth. The milk chocolate is my favorite but I just “discovered” Cookie Monstah last night and it is AMAZING!!! So excited to try more!

    • Erin

      ohh raspberry lemonade..I haven’t thought of that. So many people talk about pairing with wines, however I like the non alcohol option! We’re so happy you love the product! Thank you and #getstuffed

Add a review

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *